> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.ridgereport.news/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# State Farm's 'Exhibit 133' Roof Memo Is Public. Here's What It Says About Hail Claims, Agents and Roofers.
- URL: https://www.ridgereport.news/state-farm-exhibit-133-roof-memo-oklahoma-hail-claims-2026/
- Published: 2026-11-09T19:00:12.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-09T19:00:12.000Z
- Description: A 2021 State Farm memo filed in an Oklahoma hail case describes manager approval for full roof replacements on small hail and light wind and a falling total-roof ratio. State Farm says plaintiffs are misreading it.
- Author: Ridge Report
- Tags: Insurance, Weather/Storms, Business

A 2021 State Farm document about how it handles wind and hail roof claims is now in the public court record in Oklahoma, and roofers who work storm claims should read what's in it. On Oct. 26, Oklahoma County District Judge Amy Palumbo ruled that the 19-page memo, known in court as "Exhibit 133," "was not created in anticipation of litigation and is not protected work-product, nor attorney-client privileged," according to court records reported by [The Hail Files](https://www.news.alliedemergencyservices.com/state-farm-exhibit-133-roof-memo-not-privileged/?ref=ridgereport.news). The homeowners in *Hursh v. State Farm* filed it publicly the next morning, and [FOX23](https://fox23.com/news/fox23-investigates/newly-released-state-farm-document-raises-questions-about-roof-claim-handling-practices?ref=ridgereport.news) reported on its contents Nov. 2.

State Farm disputes the homeowners' reading. In a statement to FOX23, the company said the document "is simply one example of State Farm's ongoing efforts to review and improve how we handle claims" and that the plaintiffs' attorneys "are misrepresenting that work." It has asked the Oklahoma Supreme Court to review the ruling. Nothing in the memo has been decided on the merits, and no court has found that State Farm underpaid anyone.

What it means for your crew

- If you work State Farm claims in hail country, assume a full replacement on small hail or light wind goes to a manager. Build the file for that reviewer, not just the field adjuster.
- Document repairability: test squares, brittleness and seal-strip checks, and proof when a shingle is discontinued.
- Keep your role clean. Document the damage and the scope, but don't negotiate coverage for the homeowner unless you're licensed to.
- Expect more of these documents to surface. Trial in Hursh is set for Dec. 7, and the AG's case is still pending.

## What's in the memo

The document is a summary prepared for a State Farm senior executive offsite in October 2021, with bracketed comments that a State Farm in-house lawyer has sworn were his, per [the court filings](https://www.news.alliedemergencyservices.com/state-farm-exhibit-133-roof-memo-not-privileged/?ref=ridgereport.news). The parts that matter most to roofers:

- **Manager sign-off.** A step rolled out to all states in January 2021 "requires claim team manager approval for full roof replacements for damage potentially caused by small hail and light wind." The bracketed comment next to it: "Our adversaries could say this places pressure on front line claim reps to not replace a roof."
- **Fewer full replacements.** The ratio of total roof replacements to partial replacements fell from 3.21 to 1 (April–December 2020) to 1.95 to 1 (January–September 2021). The memo says that analysis doesn't account for event severity.
- **More claims closed without payment.** The share of wind and hail claims closed without payment rose 17 and 13 points year over year, respectively.
- **Roofers named.** Among themes from agent conversations, the memo lists: "Roofing contractors are negatively portraying State Farm to customers and agents," and agents saying "reputable roofing contractors" don't agree with State Farm's damage evaluations.
- **State Farm's own accuracy numbers.** The memo reports 2021 surveys finding "94-95% accuracy in scoping to repair or replace" and says a later change from closed-without-payment to a total-roof payment "may not indicate that the initial call was incorrect."

FOX23 also reported that the word "tactics" was crossed out and replaced with "action steps" in the draft. The homeowners' attorney, Hannah Whitten, told FOX23 the document is "State Farm's own words." State Farm's position, per its filings, is that the bracketed notes are a lawyer's advice on wording and "do not establish or direct the underlying claim handling practices."

## Where the case stands

The fight over the document isn't finished. On Nov. 2, State Farm filed an emergency motion asking the court to strike the filing and remove the memo from the public docket, arguing it was still designated confidential under the case's protective order, according to [The Hail Files' docket review](https://www.news.alliedemergencyservices.com/state-farm-exhibit-133-roof-memo-not-privileged/?ref=ridgereport.news). State Farm also moved Oct. 29 to disqualify Judge Palumbo and withdrew that motion Nov. 3 without prejudice. A hearing on four motions, including two summary-judgment motions, is set for Nov. 13, with trial scheduled to start Dec. 7\. A companion case in Comanche County has been pushed to February 2027.

This is the same set of Oklahoma cases behind the [attorney general's suit against State Farm](https://www.ridgereport.news/oklahoma-ag-state-farm-hail-focus-suit-2026/) we covered in September, and part of a wider trend of [state AGs moving on hail claims](https://www.ridgereport.news/state-ags-hail-claims-rewrite-storm-contracts-2026/). In a separate federal case, a Tulsa judge granted State Farm summary judgment on a homeowner's bad-faith claim Oct. 22, and State Farm is arguing company-wide evidence like this memo is irrelevant to individual claim files.

## The Ridge Report take

Whatever a jury decides, the memo confirms something storm contractors have said for years: on small-hail and light-wind losses, a full replacement at State Farm needed a manager's sign-off starting in 2021\. That makes the file you hand the adjuster more important, not less. Photos, test squares, discontinued-product evidence and a clear repairability argument are what move a claim up the chain. Just keep the line clear between documenting damage and practicing public adjusting, which state AGs are watching closely.

## Sources

[FOX23, "Newly released State Farm document raises questions about roof claim handling practices," Nov. 2, 2026 (updated Nov. 4)](https://fox23.com/news/fox23-investigates/newly-released-state-farm-document-raises-questions-about-roof-claim-handling-practices?ref=ridgereport.news). [The Hail Files (Allied Emergency Services), "Judge Rules State Farm's 'Exhibit 133' Roof Memo Isn't Privileged," Oct. 29, 2026, updated Nov. 5, based on court filings in Hursh v. State Farm, Oklahoma County No. CJ-2025-2626](https://www.news.alliedemergencyservices.com/state-farm-exhibit-133-roof-memo-not-privileged/?ref=ridgereport.news). [The Cool Down, citing KFOR, Nov. 5, 2026](https://www.thecooldown.com/green-business/state-farm-roof-replacement-claims-pressure/?ref=ridgereport.news).