Shingle Makers Take On IBHS Over FORTIFIED's 15-Year Roof Cap. Here's What to Tell Homeowners.
The asphalt shingle makers say IBHS's 10-year aging study is too thin to support a 15-year FORTIFIED cutoff. IBHS says the cap is an eligibility limit, not a death date for the roof. Contractors are stuck explaining the difference.
The fight over how long a FORTIFIED shingle roof stays FORTIFIED is now out in the open. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association (ARMA) has published a technical review attacking the Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety's 10-year shingle aging study, and this week the trade and insurance press picked it up. Roofing Contractor got IBHS on the record Nov. 4, and Insurance Journal followed Nov. 9 with the insurer side of the argument.
At stake is the rule we covered when IBHS announced it: starting Jan. 1, 2027, an asphalt shingle roof can keep its FORTIFIED designation for no more than 15 years. ARMA says the study behind that cap was run with "non-standard testing protocols, unrepresentative grab-sampling, and incomplete probabilistic modeling," and it's asking insurers not to turn it into broader underwriting limits. IBHS says the 15-year line is about program eligibility, not about when a roof wears out.
What ARMA is arguing
Per ARMA's statement and its full brief, the association's main objections are:
- Sample size. IBHS's 10-year work covered 14 products from seven manufacturers. ARMA says that's a sliver of the market and that single production batches can't stand in for whole product lines.
- A mid-study change in test method. IBHS moved from an edge-clamp uplift test to a beam procedure partway through. ARMA calls the beam method "highly variable" and says longer wood beams flex and cause premature edge peeling. It also objects that the procedure used a polyurethane adhesive on the shingle surface, which it says is chemically incompatible with asphalt.
- Old shingles, old installs. ARMA says the report doesn't separate 3-tab shingles, which it puts at less than 4% of today's residential market, from architectural products, and it leans on older literature that reflects practices like racking that manufacturers now advise against.
- Results left out of the headline. Three of the nine 10-year specimens from IBHS's Richburg, S.C., farm didn't lose uplift resistance compared with their five-year results, according to Roofing Contractor's read of the report. ARMA says the conclusions don't reflect that.
ARMA told Roofing Contractor it opposes the cap outright. "Contractors who underwent training and followed the FORTIFIED program to install higher-cost roofing systems risk losing credibility with clients after 10 to 15 years, or even sooner," the association said.
What IBHS says
IBHS acknowledges the test change in its own report and says sensitivity testing found more variance with the beam method but no systematic bias that would lower median uplift resistance. It also says the aging study was only one input. "Collectively, that work provided the technical basis for establishing a practical limit on FORTIFIED designation eligibility, which is not meant to suggest that every asphalt shingle roof has the same service life," Fred Malik, managing director of FORTIFIED at IBHS, told Roofing Contractor.
Two details from IBHS matter for the field. First, the short-term hit is small: Malik said fewer than 50 homes will reach the 15-year limit in the next three years. Second, the study's own findings are more nuanced than "old shingles fail." Average uplift resistance rose over the first five years, fell between years five and 10, and still finished above the lab baseline on average. Shingles at the southern farm declined faster than the same products up north, which IBHS ties to heat and sun exposure. The Sept. 29 bulletin also states that the rule "does not establish asphalt shingle service life," per Insurance Journal.
Why insurers are watching
The real worry for roofers is whether the cap spreads past FORTIFIED. Insurance Journal notes Florida law already bars carriers from non-renewing a policy solely because a roof is under 15 years old, and a few other states, including Texas and Virginia, have rules on roof-age-only renewals. But carriers still price on age. "We price on the age and condition of the roof. It is the single-largest rate factor," Security First Insurance president Melissa Burt DeVriese told the publication. Mike Silvers, director of technical services for the Florida Roofing and Sheetmetal Association, pushed back: "A lot of folks in the insurance industry don't understand that shingles are not all the same."
This lands in a rough year for shingle volume. U.S. shingle shipments fell 13% in Q3, and manufacturers have every reason to resist anything that shortens the story they tell homeowners about roof life.
What to watch
IBHS confirmed to Homepros that the cap takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, and declined to comment on ARMA's brief. ARMA says it welcomes "open dialogue and collaboration" with IBHS. Watch for whether any state insurance department or carrier cites the IBHS study in a filing. That's the moment the debate stops being about a designation and starts being about coverage.
Sources
Roofing Contractor, "ARMA Challenges IBHS 15-Year FORTIFIED Roof Limit," Nov. 4, 2026. Insurance Journal, "Manufacturers Hammer IBHS Over 15-Year Roof Age Limit for Fortified Designation," Nov. 9, 2026. ARMA, "ARMA Responds to Recent IBHS Report" and full technical brief (PDF). Homepros, "ARMA pushes back on IBHS shingle report, FORTIFIED age cap," Oct. 29, 2026.