State Farm Will Reopen Five Years of Oklahoma Hail Claims. Here's What Roofers Should Do Before the Letters Go Out
Oklahoma regulators found State Farm improperly denied roof claims and secured a $45M+ settlement that reopens wind and hail claims closed without payment from 2021 through 2025.
Oklahoma homeowners whose State Farm wind or hail roof claims were closed without payment between Jan. 1, 2021, and Dec. 31, 2025, are getting a second look. On Nov. 13 the Oklahoma Insurance Department (OID) released a market conduct examination that found State Farm Fire and Casualty improperly denied or underpaid roof damage claims, and announced a settlement worth more than $45 million.
For roofers working Oklahoma, this is the most concrete reopen-the-file opportunity the state has seen. It is also a process with rules, and shops that treat it like a canvassing free-for-all will create problems for themselves and their customers.
What the settlement says
- At least $35 million for consumer restitution. If eligible claims need more, OID and State Farm will agree on an additional amount, per the department.
- $10 million to Strengthen Oklahoma Homes, the state's grant program for FORTIFIED roofs. OID says participants who fortify see average premium savings of about $700.
- $2.86 million in fines and exam expenses, on top of the $45 million.
- "Closed without payment" is broad. OID says it includes partial payments and claims ruled under the deductible.
- An independent third-party administrator, picked jointly by OID and State Farm, reviews each eligible claim, including the original file and any new evidence the policyholder submits. If the administrator says the claim qualifies, State Farm pays under the homeowner's policy.
- Homeowners must opt in. State Farm will mail OID-approved notices explaining how. OID says it will help consumers recognize that the outreach is legitimate.
How the exam was done
According to the Journal Record's read of the report, examiners randomly selected 181 claims closed without payment. Fifty-eight homeowners agreed to let Cherry PI Engineering, under contract to OID, inspect their roofs. Examiners reviewed 42 claims and found 25 violations of the state's Unfair Claim Settlement Practices Act: three for failing to tell homeowners their claim was denied, and 22 for failing to attempt good-faith settlement. Commissioner Glen Mulready said no other state has put independent engineers on roofs during a traditional market conduct exam.
State Farm disputes the findings. The company said it handled more than 100,000 Oklahoma claims in five years, that a limited review "should not be mistaken for a complete picture," and that it posted more than $178.5 million in net underwriting losses in Oklahoma from 2021 through 2025.
The litigation isn't over
The settlement is a regulatory action. The Oklahoma Attorney General's separate suit against State Farm in Cleveland County continues, with a Dec. 7 hearing on State Farm's motion to disqualify outside counsel Whitten Burrage, according to the Journal Record. The private Hursh case is still pending in Oklahoma County. The Ridge Report covered the AG suit in September.
What to do now
- Pull your own files. Look for State Farm denials, partial payments, and under-deductible calls on Oklahoma jobs with 2021–2025 loss dates. Your inspection photos, measurements, and notes are the new evidence the administrator can weigh.
- Wait for the official notice before pitching. The opt-in runs through State Farm's approved letters. Point past customers to that letter and to OID. Don't imply you can file for them or that payment is guaranteed.
- Re-document what changed. A roof hit in 2022 may have taken more storms since. Date-stamp everything and separate old damage from new so the file holds up.
- Watch for scam traffic. OID is already warning homeowners to verify outreach. Expect door knockers using "State Farm settlement" as a hook, and keep your own messaging clean.
- Talk FORTIFIED on reroofs. The extra $10 million for Strengthen Oklahoma Homes means more grant-funded FORTIFIED jobs. If you aren't certified, this is a reason to look at it.
Timelines for the notices and the administrator haven't been published yet. We'll update when OID posts them.
Sources
- Oklahoma Insurance Department, "Mulready Announces More Than $45 Million in State Farm Settlement Following Extensive Roof Claims Investigation," Nov. 13, 2026. oid.ok.gov/111226
- Katrina Crumbacher, "State Farm agrees to $45M deal over Oklahoma wind and hail claims," The Journal Record, Nov. 13, 2026. journalrecord.com